I went to Plinky because I wanted something thought provoking to write about that made me analyze what something means to me. The prompt that struck me was “What song can you listen to over an over again? Why?”. Three songs came to mind, but I am sure I have several more.
1. ‘Vermillion Pt. 2′ by Slipknot
2. ’3 Libras’ by A Perfect Circle
3. ‘Judith’ by A Perfect Circle
Yes, there is a Pt. 1 to Vermillion, but it’s more lyrically grotesque than I like. Now that we’ve got that out of the way, on to the reasons.

Vermillion Pt. 2
She seemed dressed in all of me, stretched across my shame
All the torment and the pain, leaked through and covered me
I’d do anything to have her to myself, just to have her for myself
Now I don’t know what to do, I don’t know what to do when she makes me sane.
This first verse of Vermilion Pt. 2 is amazing to me. When it comes on it makes me think of someone I once held too dear to me. “Dressed in all of me” about how I was always caring for her and her needs. “All the torment and the pain leaked through and covered me” I took on all of her troubles, I always wanted to fix her and every time she healed, I hurt. “I’d do anything to have her to myself” sounds creepy as hell, let’s be honest, but when I was hanging out with her I always wanted to build her up and make her feel smart and pretty and protect her from any negativity because to be really honest, she was extremely thin-skinned.
She is everything to me, the unrequited dream
The song that no one sings, the unattainable
She’s a myth that I have to believe in
All I need to make it real is one more reason
I don’t know what to do, I don’t know what to do when she makes me sad.
The friendship was very one sided where I mostly catered to her and her well-being. Everyone always asked why I was friends with her and didn’t understand our friendship. I cared a lot about her, more than I had really for any of my other friends at the time. I was always there when she needed me and would pick her up in any instance that her and her boyfriend turned husband were arguing. She had some downfalls, but she was my best friend.
But I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me
A catch in my throat, choke, torn into pieces I won’t, no!
I don’t wanna be this…
But I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me I won’t let this build up inside of me
She isn’t real I can’t make her real
She isn’t real I can’t make her real
We had a falling out and it happened to be when I was in the middle of a shit-storm of mania. I don’t remember all the details, but these last pieces of the song help me realize that as much as I put her up on a pedestal, she should have returned the same kind of love and friendship. And when he says, “I don’t wanna be this..” it’s like me saying I don’t want to be so co-dependent. And when sang, “She isn’t real, I can’t make her real” means my friend that I have created to be in my head, she never was and I couldn’t make her.

3 Libras
I threw you the obvious and you flew with it on your back,
A name in your recollection, thrown down among a million same. Difficult not to feel a little bit disappointed and passed over
When I’ve looked right through to see you naked and oblivious
And you don’t. See. Me…
I was sexually abused at 14, but it didn’t involve rape since I was lucky enough to have been menstruating on the day, he did touch and do something else down there, but no penetration thank God. Not even a year later I met Greg. Well I knew him in Middle School, but now he lived 2 doors down from me. We became pretty close friends and I had a mad crush on him because suffice to say he was fucking hot. I liked our friendship, I could go to him with anything and he was just as much as a disturbed teen as I was. Actually maybe more so. He started dating another friend of mine and damn it if I am not territorial. He’d only been dating her like a week or two when Greg and I decided to have sex. Yes, it’s cheating, but we were basically kids I think we deserve a little slack—& I know having sex and being ‘basically’ a kid do not go hand in hand, but that was what it was—it was October 6th, one day after my birthday and 2 days after the chick he was seeing’s birthday.
He’s tall and well endowed so it freaking hurt, but we got accustomed and a whole Orgy album later we were done. I didn’t realize how emotional it would be for me until I got into his shower. I cried. I don’t know if I was crying because I really liked him and I felt cheap now or if I felt as if I indeed lost something. Or if I felt dirty like I did after that creep asshole molested me. Maybe it was all the above. I came back to his room and he asked me if I was OK 15 times and I said I was fine and that I had to go.
But I threw you the obvious
Just to see if there’s more behind the
Eyes of a fallen angel, Eyes of a tragedy
Here I am expecting just a little bit
Too much from the wounded
But I see, see through it all
See through, see you
Greg’s situation was a little much at the time, a little meaning that a girl had trapped (I was her friend so I know for a fact she did since she told me the same story he had) him into having a child with her. Greg changed a lot from that. He harbored more anger than I’ve seen in anyone. Even when he was experiencing different emotions, it was there festering inside. So yes, he was wounded and more so a tragedy.
Cause I threw you the obvious
To see what occurs behind the
Eyes of a fallen angel, Eyes of a tragedy
Oh well, oh well
Apparently nothing,
Apparently nothing at all
You don’t, you don’t
You don’t see me
You don’t, you don’t
You don’t see me at all…
We tried to have a relationship for the first time when we were young adults, before I went off to college and before he moved away. It was oil and water. I drove to see him a couple times when I was back from college and we tried to maintain our friendship. Then he came back here for a visit and for a weird reason wanted to tell me that he had feelings for another girl that had lived on our street and gone to school with us. He was hurt and mad because he had seen her first and she laughed in his face. I tried to explain maybe she was just taken back since when he dated her once when we were young, he cheated on her bad (not with me). He told me not to tell her that he told me this, but her and I hung out and when I was tipsy with a few girlfriends it came out and Greg dropped completely out of my life. He was my first real crush and this song is my song to him because I first heard it when I was hanging out with him in his old room.
Judith
As much as many people say that Maynard is against religion, he sure makes a lot of songs that touch on it, in fact this whole album that ’3 Libras’ and ‘Judith’ is on, each song kind of brushes topics of religion. He could very well be against organized religion, hell he may be anti-Christian. But his songs almost question the ideas of following such faith and you have to have questions in your faith or you are walking blind. This song is the one that challenges the whole idea of Jesus and religion.
You’re such an inspiration
For the ways that I will Never ever choose to be
Oh so many ways for me to show you
How your savior has abandoned you
That beginning, “you’re such an inspiration for the ways that I will never ever choose to be” is strong. I truly love this song when I am pissed off or need to vent through music which I do a lot. My opinion on this song meaning would be he is talking to those devout believers that walk blindly and question nothing. The close minded, the non-seekers.
Fuck your God, your Lord, your Christ
He did this, took all you had and
Left you this way,
Still you pray, never stray, never
Taste of the fruit, never thought to question “Why?”
It’s not like you killed someone
It’s not like you drove a hateful spear into his side
Praise the one who left you broken down and paralyzed
The first testament of the Bible is supposed to give the history of the way it was before Jesus came down to spread the word of God. Well if you focus on the first testament, which a lot of the Christians don’t, God was very different. He seemed more spiteful. His first spiteful deed being The Tree of Knowledge. The garden of Eden was supposed to be lovely and Adam and Eve true followers of God as they were his creation. If the garden is so wonderful, why would God allow a serpent who is supposedly the fallen angel into the garden to seduce Eve. Why would he create the tree of Knowledge and tell Adam and Eve they could not eat from it. He wanted them to do so. It created free will, but then again he punished them for doing so because it went against his word. It pisses me off that as humans today we still get the painful menstruation and labor for something Eve did. All Adam got was hard work in the fields, I don’t see every man now days working in the fields. The Bible is sexist and created by man and this is why Maynard is saying fuck YOUR God, YOUR Lord, YOUR Christ because the God I believe in (more me speaking than him now) would not be this way. In Leviticus alone, we were allowed to have slaves. That sounds more of a man back then than any Creator telling the man that. Another part that matches the Bible like the Tree of Knowledge is Judith and Jesus. Judith turned on Jesus and Jesus knew it was coming all along and he even said at this last supper that one of his disciples was going to turn on him. It is also being studied to see if Mary Magdalen really was a prostitute that Jesus helped or if she was actually one of his disciples. Wouldn’t that throw the Catholic Church through a loop?
Oh so many ways for me to show you
How your dogma has abandoned you
Pray to your Christ, to your God
Never taste of the fruit, never stray, never break,
Never choke on a lie even though he’s the one who
Did this to you, you never thought to question “Why?”
It’s not like you killed someone
It’s not like you drove a spiteful spear into his side
Talk to Jesus Christ as if he knows the reasons why
He did it all for you…
Music is my life. I don’t play it and when I sing I don’t have the best voice but it helps me to feel all my emotions freely without judgment. What’s better than that?
Like this:
Like Loading...